Contract Review Checklist: Red Flag Version
Before you sign or approve any contract, it’s helpful to run it through a **red‑flag checklist**. This helps you spot dangerous terms or hidden traps that could cost you later. Below is a checklist of key warning signs to watch for.
🔎 Pre‑Review Notes
- Have the final and all prior drafts available for comparison
- Keep a separate document or margin for notes & comments
- Know your priorities (what clauses matter most to you)
1. Definitions & Interpretation
- Are key terms properly defined and capitalized?
- “Ambiguous” definitions or reused words without clarity
- Cross‑references that refer to definitions inconsistently
2. Scope / Deliverables / Obligations
- Vague or open-ended obligations (“as needed”, “reasonable efforts”)
- Undefined metrics, standards, or performance levels
- Unilateral rights to change scope or deliverables
3. Payment & Fees
- Unclear payment schedule or conditions
- Automatic deductions, escalations, or penalties
- No cap on fees or interest for late payments
4. Term, Renewal & Termination
- Automatic renewals with tight cancellation windows
- No clear termination for convenience or “no fault” exit
- No “cure” period before termination for breach
- Survival terms that last too long (or forever) without reason
5. Liability, Indemnification & Insurance
- Unlimited liability or no caps
- Broad indemnity covering everything, including others’ negligence
- Defense costs included without limit
- No requirement for insurance or proof of coverage
6. Confidentiality & Intellectual Property
- Overbroad definition of “confidential information”
- No exceptions for required disclosures (by law, regulation)
- IP ownership transfers, licensing, or ambiguous rights
- No carve-out for residual knowledge or general skills
7. Change Control & Amendments
- Verbal or informal changes allowed
- No requirement that amendments be in writing and signed
- Amendment rights only for the other party, not you
8. Dispute Resolution & Governing Law
- Unfavorable jurisdiction or venue clause
- No requirement for mediation or negotiation before going to court
- Mandatory arbitration with limited rights of appeal
9. Miscellaneous Provisions
- Severability clauses absent or weak
- Entire agreement / merger clauses that shut out prior promises
- Force majeure clauses too narrow or absent
- No audit or inspection rights
- Unclear notices clause (where/how to send notices)
10. Execution & Formalities
- Missing signatures, dates, or printed names
- Required witnesses, notary, or seals missing
- No counterpart or electronic signature clause
Conclusion
Use this checklist before you finalize or sign any contract. Each red flag is a chance to ask questions, negotiate changes, or request clarifications. If you want, I can run a red-flag review for your specific contract—upload it and I’ll walk you through the risks in plain English.
FAQ
- How exhaustive is this checklist?
- This is a high‑level, red‑flag review. Some contracts may require deeper legal review depending on complexity.
- Should I always amend contracts with red flags?
- Not always—but understanding them will help you decide whether to negotiate, accept with caution, or walk away.
- Can missing formalities invalidate a contract?
- Possibly, depending on state law and contract type. That’s why checking signatures, dates, and witnessing is important.
- Are these red flags always fatal?
- No—some can be managed or mitigated via amendments, carve-outs, or fair negotiation.
- How do I use this checklist with your service?
- You can upload your contract, and I’ll highlight these red flags and explain what they mean for you in plain English.